Fight Club: Why Tyler Durden is a Minimalist

Posted: Wednesday, January 11, 2012 by Tyler Durden in

39 Responses to “Fight Club: Why Tyler Durden is a Minimalist”

Comments

Read below or add a comment...
  1. My BF finally watched the movie and had to re-watch it again to get a hold of all the lessons.
    He loved it. Fight Club is now like “his movie”, with all of the minimalist quotes on there about not owning stuff, living life, setting goals.
    Fabulous :)
    Thanks for coming by! Added you to my blogroll & RSS feed. :D
    • Josh & Ryan
      Thanks for adding us to your blogroll and RSS. We really appreciate it. Also, we added a link to some clips from Fight Club if you’re interested in watching a few of those minimalist quotes.
  2. Thanks for this post! I never realized how much minimalism was incorporated into such a popular, powerful film. I’m going to take a look at your Fight Club clips and see if I should share any of the on my blog.
    Ironically, one of the movies I just tossed into my ‘to-sell at Half-Price Books bag’ minutes ago just happens to be Fight Club.
    :)
    • Joshua & Ryan
      Laura,
      Great movie, although there is obviously certain kind of perniciousness associated with Durden’s extra-extreme anti-consumerism. That said, it’s a great movie and a great novel, Chuck P. is a literary genius.
      Joshua
  3. David
    Hey guys..great post. Good meeting you at the Everett Bogue tweetup as well!
  4. Ryan Fletcher
    Tyler Durden is not a minimalist. Why don’t you go polish your Scandinavian furniture and think about it. That’s a really respectable wardrobe you’ve accumulated; you’re almost complete. I would be careful about “abdicating” anybody’s moral repulsiveness, just kidding. Like the blog, keep it up, right up.
  5. Tom
    I loved Fight Club and its various messages about consumerism and personal priorities. It reflects many of my own thoughts on the subject. Unfortunately, I came to most of those conclusions *after* I’d already built my golden cage. Worse, I’d built the cage for more than just myself. While I could, conceivably, break out of that cage, it would be at the cost of more than just myself – my family would bear the real price of that new freedom.
    • Joshua & Ryan
      Tom,
      I’m glad you like our messages about consumerism; thanks for the compliment. Same thing for us: we had our own personal kingdoms, complete with big houses, cars, and toys (and a bunch of debt and billd to accompany that stuff).
      You might be in a situation where you can’t downsize everything in 21 days, but you can start taking baby steps now. Taking some sort of action will get you some momentum, and I’m certain you can get rid of some of the excess stuff in your life. That doesn’t mean you have to live with 100 things (we certainly don’t), it just means you can get rid of the unnecessary stuff first so you can focus on what’s important in life.
      And don’t worry about your families stuff at first. Do your own thing initially and they will see the progress you’re making. Show them our site or Joshua Becker’s site (http://becomingminimalist.com) and they will see that there is a practical side to decluttering and minimalism and simplicity.
      Let us know if we can help. We appreciate your readership.
      Joshua
      P.S. I have some big news coming on 3/1/11. Stay tuned, I think it will help you understand the importance of changing your life even more.
  6. tammy
    Hey Friend, I just read about DAY 11 TRASH DAY. I really am having a Tough time Letting go of those things of SENTIMENTAL VALUE. All the childhood, college, marriage photos(no longer married) Boxes of photos from 35 MM Camera, scrapbooks, etc. Things from Special people who have passed, YOU GET MY DRIFT. I bought 4 trunks to SAVE those items. OMG. That was BEFORE I began reading ALL OF THIS. I thought buying the Trunks I would have MORE ORDER. YES I would, but that doesnt GET RID OF THE CLUTTER. It just keeps it more Organized. You have a TINY PARAGRAPH ON THIS, You say, THROW IT OUT. REALLY? I know it sounds pretty easy in your words I highlighted it and said. YES, I will do that as well. Yet I had gone through last night, and just put them in one trunk. Yet today I woke up asking? ARE THESE ITEMS DOING ANYTHING FOR YOUR PRESENT? I would LOVE to hear from others on this WORSE TASK POSSIBLE> Talk about Judgments. ALREADY & I barely mentioned this to my Mother. WRONG THING TO DO.
    HOW DO I KNOW IF YOU RESPOND TO ME?
  7. tami
    Interesting…the connection you make.
    My son MADE me read this… Then we HAD to discuss it.
    He saw and brought to light the many layers of this book.
    Thanks for the quotes!!
    p.s. Didn’t Tyler blow up his apartment?
  8. I thought a lot about Fight Club and its ties with minimalism after spinning the Trainspotting soundtrack and thinking about the John Hodge poem Choose Life this morning.
    Got me wondering why so much art with anti-consumerism messages are seen as very pernicious or aggressive? Especially given the Durden quote in regards to the parking ticket.
    Are these art works really that or is the truth still to hot too handle?
    • Will,
      Perhaps the difference has to do with the vitriolic (and complete non-objective) distain for consumerism within such art that seems aggressive. There are more subtle ways to address it in art though (have you read “The Corrections” by J. Franzen? He does a great job taking a conservative book and discussing liberal ideas via character discourse).
      Thanks for the quality comment.
      Take care,
      Joshua
  9. Sean
    Hey fellas,
    I’ve been on TheMinimalists for quite some time now and haven’t posted at all in all this time. I regularly read and re-read this specific essay since it reminds of my first steps into the world of minimalism. I remember watching Fight Club when I was a teenager and really got into it, being the young rebel that I was. A few years went by and I happened to watch it again, but this time actually getting the message it sought to bring me. Ever since then this movie has become a refuge for when my consumerist desires get a better grip on my life. Though things have been going very well for quite some time now, I still occasionally struggle with the burden of wanting and having materials possessions.
    I never made the move, but I’d like to thank you guys for doing what you do. I hate saying that you’re an inspiration (not that you’re not) since it’s too often said these days and sounds typically without value. So I thought maybe a slightly edited quote from Fight Club itself would explain what I’m actually trying to say. This is for both of you;
    “You will bring me through this. As always, you will carry me – kicking and screaming – and in the end I will thank you.”
    • Sean,
      Nice to meet you online. Thanks for commenting. Turns out that less than 1% of readers comment, so welcome to the 1% club.
      I had the same experience with FC: liked it as a teenager (I think I was 18 when it came out), but then really “got it” after re-watching it years later (and reading the book as well).
      Also, I still struggle with the burden of wanting and having material possessions. The journey is the destination though, and we’ll continue the journey together.
      Love the quote! Thanks, bro.
      Keep in touch (we’re on Twitter and Facebook).
      Take care,
      Joshua
  10. Dan
    I came across your site via your guest post on Zen Habits today. Everything about your journey of minimalism and more importantly the introspection, has resonated powerfully.
    This post read like a manifesto. Its powerful and while the words are not your own, they are arranged like a well structured composition.
    I feel very inspired to push through some long standing boundaries. You guys are an inspiration.
  11. As an adult, Fight Club replaced Back to the Future as my favourite movie. :)It was a major inspiration for me in rejecting consumerism, even before I became familiar with minimalism.
  12. Nancy
    Wow…did all these quotes come from just one movie? Now I’ll have to rent this….! Thanks for posting it.
  13. Andreas
    The movie has become one of my favourites too, and encouraged me on my minimalist way. I’ve seen it before, but after your essay I see the real intention of FC. There’s just one thing I don’t get quite properly – what’s meant by the “all-singing, all-dancing” phrase? (I understand all the words, but maybe there’s some sense in it I cannot understand – English isn’t my mother tongue; btw, this is my first comment on a blog ever :) ) Thanks in advance!
  14. Andreas
    Thanks Joshua. Btw, have you recognized the guy in red putting his arm around the guy saying “it’s time for the one-and-ones” in the testicular cancer group scene in the beginning? It’s just a very short time shown, like a fifth of a second or so. I’ve just seen it and wanted to “share it”.
  15. Sadie without the S
    # 26.
    When you wake up and realize you have a house full of stuff that you’ve never used, don’t intend to use.. but haven’t given away. That’s the moment you start to reject what was and start to embrace the change.
  16. This is one bad ass essay boys! Genius. Guess what I’m watching this weekend. Cheers!
  17. pukO
    FC is definitely in my top 5 list of fav movies…
    I never knew what was in it, until this post and my awakening to achieving minimalism.
    Thank you.
  18. Spanky_Jones
    Fight Club saved my sanity. This article made my day.
  19. Benjamin
    Hi,
    You left out this crucial quote from the film:
    “Let that which does not matter…truly slide.”
    Remember the talking penguin, his power animal that said “slide.”?
    That quote is pretty minimalist! and it belongs on your list!
    Much respect,
    Benjamin
  20. Cassandra
    Hey, my name is Cassandra. I am 19 years old and I have had that last quote tattooed on my forearm since last December. Love you guys.
  21. Nate
    Good stuff. I also recommend the underrated movie The Truman Show. Not as many good quotes but the message and symbolism is strong. And be sure to watch it more than once.
  22. Laurie
    Love this movie… One of my faves and enjoying the website. I’m still crafting my non-goals for the future and I’m continually inspired. Thank you. And who wouldn’t love any more references to Edward Norton films. Especially great ones like this.

0 comments :